Tag: what happens when

LGBT, three star book, ya

What Happens When Review

Courtney/Enchanted.to.Read.You
  • Title: What Happens When
  • Author: Samantha Boyette
  • Book Form: Egalley ARC
  • Publisher: Bold Strokes Books, Inc
  • Genre: YA, Contemporary, LGBT
  • Rating: ★★★


For Molly Kennan, senior year is already an epic disaster. It feels like the whole school knows she made out with Lily at that party, and now she’s accidentally outed herself as a lesbian. Her ex-best friend is trying to ruin her life, and school generally sucks. All she wants is to drown her sorrows in sweet potato fries, but she finds herself tongue-tied by the diner’s new waitress, Zia. Zia is way out of Molly’s league. Older, beautiful, and definitely way more sophisticated. It’s probably just wishful thinking, but Molly can’t help wondering if maybe Zia is flirting with her. Despite Zia’s always-there boyfriend, Molly falls hard for her, and Zia says she feels the same way. So then why doesn’t Zia break up with her boyfriend, and why does she keep so many secrets? Then there’s Lily, who she can’t seem to stop accidentally kissing. When your head and your heart are saying two different things, which one should you listen to?

– Goodreads

Thank you to Bold Strokes Books, Inc and Netgalley for a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. These thoughts and opinions are my own.

I have recently been into LGBT fiction, so I was super excited to read this book! I also just love YA Contemporary. It is such a cute genre. I was disappointed it didn’t live up to the hype I made for it. Although this book was a three star for me, it was a very quick read. I read it over three days, but only because I was trying to finish another book for a book club.

My favorite part of What Happens When was the relationship between Abby and her brother. They’re Irish twins and are super close. Luke is there for her no matter what and I love that. I’m an only child, but if I had a sibling I hope that’s how we would be.

I didn’t like the way the LGBT kids were treated. Yes, I understand she was trying to show how bad it can be for them abuse and bullying wise. It can be bad; I’m not denying that. However, I’ve never heard of it on that scale. It almost seems a little too over the top. I went to a very conservative school in the south and the LGBT kids weren’t treated near like they were in this book.

I also didn’t like that Abby was so hung up on Zia. Maybe it’s a dumb teenage thing, always chasing after who we can’t have. But they just seemed to take it too far and Zia strung her along. The whole book I was just begging her to go to Lily who actually wanted to be with her and wasn’t afraid to show it! In the end, the MC, Molly, did show growth and maturity, which I liked. It’s always nice to see character growth.

I felt like the blurb may have been better than the book. Like I said, it was a quick read. It wasn’t awful. But I just felt like Molly was too caught up on Zia and the bullying was too over-the-top, and theatrical for reality. If you can deal with the bullying and Molly being hung up on a straight girl who may-or-may-not-be-bi and who may-or-may-not break up with her boyfriend, then you’ll probably like this book. There were good parts. I loved the ending. It was a fast read. I just wish some elements worked a little better for me.

Until next time…